Sarah,
I love this product! I received it as a birthday gift from one of my friends. At first I was skeptical because I never wear black eyeliner. I waited a very long time before I used it for the first time on a weekend. I was able to create a thin and defined line, and it wasnt too bold. I was really excited. I wouldnt say it has bad color or bad pigmentation, but I will admit it does dry out a bit. Some people say it dries out completely, but Ive had mine for a while and its still going pretty strong. Its a nice faded black color that isnt too bold. I use it outline my eyeliner mostly now. I apply a line on my top lid, and if you turn the pen tip to the side, you will get more product out. Then I put black or coal shadow over the line and it stays all day. Overall, I am very pleased, and I just ordered 2 more. Cant wait for them to come! See more
